Homonculus Fallacy
/ˌhɒməˈnkjʊləs ˈfæləsi/
Definitions
- (n.) A logical error in legal reasoning that involves assuming the existence of a fully formed entity to explain a complex process, often used to critique explanations of mental states or consciousness in law.
The judge criticized the expert witness for committing the homonculus fallacy by assuming a tiny legal mind controls all decisions.
Related terms
See also
Commentary
Avoid the homonculus fallacy in legal arguments by not presuming unexplained entities or mechanisms; clarify the basis of mental or decision-making processes without infinite regress.
This glossary is for general informational and educational purposes only. Definitions are jurisdiction-agnostic but reflect terminology and concepts primarily drawn from English and American legal traditions. Nothing herein constitutes legal advice or creates a lawyer-client relationship. Users should consult qualified counsel for advice on specific matters or jurisdictions.